Rebuttal

Rebuttal is a science fiction novella by Betsy Curtis, first published in 1956. It serves as a counterpoint to Arthur C. Clarke's 'The Star' and explores themes of faith, purpose, and immortality through a scientific lens. The story follows Father Niccolo Molina, a pathologist, as he engages in a profound dialogue with Father Phillip Burt, a crew member of the ill-fated Phoenix Nebula expedition, who grapples with existential questions about the universe's lack of divine presence. Their conversation leads to a miraculous healing and a renewed sense of faith for Father Phillip.