Peter's Rock in Mohammed's Flood, from St. Gregory the Great to St. Leo III
Peter's Rock in Mohammed's Flood, from St. Gregory the Great to St. Leo III
In this rigorous 19th-century study, T.W. Allies traces the fate of Western Christianity across two pivotal centuries, from the death of Gregory the Great in 604 to the reign of Leo III in the early 800s. This was the age when the Mediterranean world fractured: Byzantine power receded, the Islamic conquests swept across the Levant, North Africa, and Spain, and the papacy stood increasingly alone as the defender of Catholic orthodoxy. Allies writes as a committed Anglican making peace with Roman Catholicism, and his narrative pulses with a specific theological conviction, that Peter's See held firm against the 'flood' of Islam precisely because divine providence had appointed it the rock upon which Christ's church would stand. The book examines the complex dance between popes and Byzantine emperors, the iconoclast controversy, Charlemagne's coronation, and the slow emergence of Christendom as a Western political and spiritual entity. For readers interested in how the medieval world took shape, or how the papacy became the institution that would dominate European politics for a millennium, Allies provides a richly detailed, argumentatively bold portrait of the church navigating existential crisis.
About Peter's Rock in Mohammed's Flood, from St. Gregory the Great to St. Leo III
Chapter Summaries
- 1
- Allies establishes the historical context from St. Gregory's death in 604 to the rise of Charlemagne, focusing on the conflict between papal spiritual authority and Byzantine temporal control. The chapter details the Persian-Byzantine wars and the rise of Mohammed during Heraclius's reign.
- 2
- The dramatic account of Pope Martin I's Lateran Council of 649 condemning Monothelism, his subsequent arrest by Exarch Kalliopas, trial in Constantinople, and martyrdom in the Crimea. This represents the climax of papal resistance to Byzantine theological tyranny.
Key Themes
- Papal Primacy vs Imperial Authority
- The fundamental conflict between spiritual and temporal power, as Byzantine emperors attempt to control Church doctrine while Popes assert their divine authority. This tension culminates in the martyrdom of Pope Martin I.
- Orthodox Faith vs Heretical Innovation
- The battle to preserve the true doctrine of Christ's two natures, wills, and operations against the Monothelite heresy promoted by Constantinople. The Church's survival depends on maintaining doctrinal purity.
- Divine Providence in History
- Allies presents history as unfolding according to God's plan, where even disasters serve the Church's ultimate triumph. The rise of Islam coincides with Byzantine theological betrayal as divine judgment.
Characters
- Pope St. Gregory the Great(major)
- The great Pontiff who died in 604 AD, marking the end of an era. He defended Rome against Byzantine despotism and Lombard threats while maintaining papal authority.
- Emperor Phocas(major)
- Byzantine emperor (602-610) who deposed Mauritius and ruled tyrannically. Despite his cruelty, he confirmed papal primacy and gave the Pantheon to Pope Boniface IV.
- Emperor Heraclius(protagonist)
- Byzantine emperor (610-641) who achieved great military victories against Persia but fell under the influence of Patriarch Sergius and promoted the Monothelite heresy. His reign marked both triumph and theological disaster.
- Patriarch Sergius of Constantinople(antagonist)
- Patriarch from 610-638 who masterminded the Monothelite heresy through the Ecthesis. He manipulated Emperor Heraclius and attempted to undermine papal authority.
- Pope Honorius I(major)
- Pope from 625-638 whose correspondence with Sergius was later used to claim papal support for Monothelism. His successors defended his orthodoxy while acknowledging his negligence.
- Pope St. Martin I(protagonist)
- Pope from 649-655 who convened the Lateran Council condemning Monothelism. He was arrested, tried, and martyred by Emperor Constans II for defending the faith.



